A US judge has deferred a ruling on whether to approve a proposed $38bn settlement between Visa, Mastercard, and merchants over credit card processing fees.

According to a Reuters report, US District Judge Brian Cogan did not issue a ruling after a hearing in Brooklyn, New York. He said rejecting the agreement could lead to a “protracted process” if the 21-year-old case proceeded to trial.

Access deeper industry intelligence

Experience unmatched clarity with a single platform that combines unique data, AI, and human expertise.

Find out more

The proposed agreement would reduce some card acceptance fees paid by merchants and allow businesses to decline certain Visa and Mastercard card categories. It would cover more than 12 million merchants, although opponents have said the changes could affect more than 20 million businesses.

Judge Cogan granted preliminary approval for the settlement in June. A separate judge rejected an earlier $30bn agreement in June 2024, finding that proposed settlement insufficient.

The case concerns allegations that Visa, Mastercard, and banks violated US antitrust law through the collection of swipe fees. Merchants pay these fees when customers use cards.

Under the proposed settlement, Visa and Mastercard would reduce swipe fees by 0.1 percentage point for five years. They would also cap fees on standard consumer cards at 1.25% for eight years.

The agreement would end the “Honor All Cards” rule, which requires merchants that accept Visa or Mastercard payments to accept all cards issued by the respective network.

Merchants would instead be able to choose whether to accept cards in three categories: commercial cards, premium consumer cards, including rewards cards, and standard consumer cards.

The Merchants Payments Coalition told Reuters Visa and Mastercard swipe fees in the US totalled $118.8bn in 2025, rising from $25.6bn in 2009. The coalition said the average fee was 2.36%.

Joseph Stiglitz, a Nobel Prize-winning economist, and Keith Leffler, a University of Washington professor, were hired by the plaintiffs to assess the proposed changes. They said the agreement could save merchants $38bn by 2031 and generate $224bn in overall benefits, including for consumers.

The court received more than 1,000 objections to the settlement, including objections from Walmart and the National Retail Federation.

Opponents argued that merchants would continue to pay high fees for rewards cards. They also said the agreement would not allow merchants to choose among individual card issuers, such as accepting cards issued by one bank while declining those issued by another.

Mithun Mansinghani, a lawyer representing the National Association of Convenience Stores and Circle K, told the court that the settlement did not introduce reforms intended to increase competition among banks and other card issuers.

Meanwhile, the Electronic Payments Coalition supported the settlement. Its members include Visa, Mastercard, Bank of America, Capital One, Chase, and Citibank.

American Express and Discover, which is owned by Capital One, are not included in the proposed settlement.