For almost 50 years, section 75 of the Consumer Credit Act has given UK consumers one of the strongest protections available when a credit purchase goes wrong. For qualifying purchases, the creditor can be held jointly and severally liable with the supplier for breach of contract or misrepresentation. That gives consumers a second route to their money. For example, goods are faulty, never arrive or the business collapses.
The principle remains powerful, but commerce in 2026 looks very different from commerce in the 1970s. Consumers increasingly buy through marketplaces, booking platforms and payment services, so the business selling the product, the platform taking the booking and the company processing the payment may all be different. Section 75 depends on the relationship between debtor, creditor and supplier. Another party in the chain does not automatically remove protection, but it can make that relationship harder to establish.
Recent concerns raised by Which? illustrate the point. Consumers may reasonably assume that paying by credit card protects them however they reach the seller. In practice, the contractual and payment arrangements behind a transaction can determine whether a claim succeeds.
Consumers should know what protection they are using
Section 75 and chargeback are often treated as interchangeable, but they’re not, because Section 75 is a statutory protection purely for credit. Chargeback is a process governed by card scheme rules, which can also apply to debit card purchases. Both are valuable, but the rules, timescales and basis for a claim differ.
To a consumer who just wants their money back, those distinctions may seem academic. To merchants, issuers and acquirers trying to establish what happened, they matter. Travel shows why: a single trip can involve an airline or hotel, a travel agent, a booking platform and a payment provider. When something goes wrong, working out who supplied what, what was promised and who was responsible can quickly become difficult.
Good records protect both sides
Effective consumer protection should make it easier for genuine customers to obtain redress. It should also allow merchants to challenge claims the evidence does not support. Clear transaction records, terms and conditions, booking details, communications and proof of fulfilment can all help establish what actually happened.
Disputes are sometimes framed as a battle between consumer and merchant, but a well-functioning system should reach the right outcome on the evidence. Weak or ambiguous records benefit nobody, because they can leave a legitimate customer waiting longer for money they are owed and a merchant less able to defend a properly fulfilled transaction.
The next challenge is already emerging
AI-powered shopping agents may increasingly search, compare and initiate purchases on a consumer’s behalf, which can make transaction journeys even less visible to the customer. The question for Section 75 is not so much whether AI changes its purpose as whether the payment ecosystem keeps clear enough records of who supplied the goods or services, what was promised and whether those obligations were met. The Government is modernising the wider Consumer Credit Act, but has left Section 75 out of the current round of reforms, citing its complexity and the further policy work needed. When policymakers
return to it, the debate should reflect how people actually buy today and how complex payment chains affect everyone involved. The goal should be strong protection for genuine consumers, with enough clarity and evidence for everyone in the payment chain to understand what happened and where responsibility lies. Almost 50 years on, the principle behind Section 75 still holds, but the task now is making sure the framework around it keeps pace.
Tracy Cray, Managing Director of UK & Europe, Chargebacks911
